I'm bad at giving gifts
Nobody ever taught me how, and it doesn't come naturally. Until I read your answers, I wasn't really sure how to give a good gift.
Like a lot of people, I get pretty wrapped up in my own life. I'm not always a great listener, and it takes intentional work for me to notice the things people want. Last weekend, my bestie Arwen tried my PopSocket on her own phone and said she liked it. It didn't even pop into my mind that it would make a good Christmas present until she said, "You could get me this for Christmas." Honestly, it probably never would have.
So this season, we asked you two questions: what's the best gift you've ever gotten, and what do you wish people would stop buying you? I was hoping for a cheat sheet on how to gift better. What I actually learned is that I just need to be a friend and family member who listens better. That means noticing when the people I love mention something they'd love to try but are too busy to jump into right now.
The answers were honest, funny, and really specific. They also came back to the same few truths again and again. So if you're shopping for a plus size person you love this year, here's what our community actually wants you to know.
What makes a gift great
Nobody told us about an expensive gift that impressed them. They told us about gifts that proved someone was paying attention.
Gifts that say "I see you"
- A painting of someone's two cats, made by a friend. "One of my favorite gifts ever."
- Notebooks brought back from international travels by a partner who isn't into stationery at all, but knows their person is.
- Taking a piece of art someone already owns and loves, and getting it framed so they can finally display it.
- A souvenir someone forgot to buy for themselves on a trip.
Things they'd never buy for themselves
A few people described the gift that sits right between "I want it" and "I can't justify it." One friend tracked down a vintage Casio watch that was hard to find. It wasn't super expensive, but it felt like a waste of money to buy for themselves. Another got Le Creuset cookware from their wife and named it their best gift, full stop.
The thing they actually asked for
One person's best gift ever was a Nintendo 64. They had stared at it every single time their family walked into Toys R Us, and finally got it for Christmas. If someone tells you what they want, believe them.
Gifts that help with real life
Sometimes the most meaningful gift isn't an object at all. One community member told us someone paid off about $1,000 of their medical bills. It was the most practically useful gift they have ever received.
Experiences that unfold
One of our favorite answers was a butterfly garden kit. It came with everything needed to raise larvae and release them as butterflies, and it fit in a townhouse at about 1' x 1' x 2'. "Every day I saw new developments, and it was a genuine joy to watch them grow and transform."
Useful things that get used up
Dish towels, spices and maybe something they already use every day. A few people told us they love consumables, but one also said they are done with more stuff. It's definitely important to know your person here.
The ick list
This is where the answers got really consistent.
Clothes that guess their size
This was the number one ick, by a mile. The random XL t-shirt. The sweater three sizes too big. One person put it plainly: when that happens, they can't help thinking, "Is THAT how big you think I am?" It stings even more when it comes from someone close to their own size.
Sizing is also all over the place, something most plus size people know but some straight size people don't get. I own pieces labeled 4X and pieces labeled XL from different brands, and they fit the same. So even if you totally had the intention of the clothing fitting them well, it might not land like you expect.
Gifts with an agenda
No clothes in a smaller size "for motivation." No diet cookbooks or exercise equipment they didn't ask for. Ew, it's gross. Even if your loved one is on a journey to change their body, that's not your place. JUST DON'T DO IT!
Cute little things and clutter
Dollar store candy, little plastic decorations, a kitchen gadget that solves a problem nobody has. Lots of you are trying to live intentionally and don't want random stuff stuffed in drawers. As one person said, if they don't already have a spot for it, they don't want it. Another had a great suggestion: if you see something beautiful that made you think of them, send them a photo of it instead.
If you really want to give clothes
It's not that clothes are off the table, they just need to come from someone who actually knows. Several of you said the only people who get clothing right are fellow plus size friends, a mom, or a sister. One sister finds cool secondhand pieces that both fit and match her sibling's style.
If that's not you yet, here's how to get it right:
- Ask first. Get an exact size for the specific brand, because sizing isn't consistent from one label to the next.
- Know their style. A piece that fits but isn't something they would wear still ends up in a drawer.
- Include a gift receipt. Make swapping easy and no big deal.
- When in doubt, let them choose. Gift cards may not be as fun to open, but they can make the person feel a lot more comfortable.
A quick cheat sheet
Give more of this:
- Something tied to a specific thing they love (pets, hobbies, collections)
- The thing they have mentioned wanting more than once
- A nicer version of something they use every day
- Framing art they already have
- An experience
- Help with a real-life cost
Skip this:
- Clothes in a guessed size
- Anything meant to "motivate" body changes
- Cheap trinkets and clutter
The best gifts our community told us about all had one thing in common: someone was paying attention. Plus size people deserve gifts that fit their lives, the same way we deserve gear that fits our bodies.
I'm so grateful for this community and how it teaches me something new every day!